
Andre Ruddock’s defence team says it will appeal his murder conviction after a jury found him guilty of killing 39-year-old Taneka Gardner at Pathways International Kingdom Restoration Ministries in St James.
The seven-member jury returned a 6–1 majority guilty verdict in the Home Circuit Court on Monday, November 9. Ruddock is scheduled to be sentenced on January 22, 2027. Justice Leighton Pusey ordered a social enquiry report ahead of sentencing, the Jamaica Observer reports.
Gardner was killed on October 17, 2021. The prosecution’s case was that Ruddock killed her on instructions from the church’s now-deceased leader, Kevin Smith, during what prosecutors described as a sacrificial ritual.
The verdict followed an initial 5–2 division. Justice Pusey directed jurors to continue deliberating, explaining that a majority verdict could not be accepted before at least two hours of deliberations. Six eventually found Ruddock guilty.
Defence disappointed, appeal planned
Lead defence attorney Anthony Williams said the team had expected an acquittal. According to Radio Jamaica, he maintained that cross-examination had exposed contradictions and weaknesses in the prosecution’s evidence.
Williams acknowledged the challenge presented by admissions attributed to Ruddock, including a caution statement, a question-and-answer document, oral admissions and video-recorded material. The defence maintained that police intimidation and physical abuse had produced those admissions. These were defence allegations, not established findings of police misconduct.
The Gleaner reports that Williams, who represented Ruddock alongside Venice Brown, said the team had received instructions to appeal. He said Ruddock continued to maintain his innocence.
The defence’s position at trial was that Smith killed Gardner. Ruddock gave sworn evidence denying responsibility and alleging that police forced him to accept blame.
Williams defended putting Ruddock on the witness stand, saying the team considered it necessary given the evidence against him. He also defended not calling further witnesses, saying his client had not instructed him to do so and emphasising that the prosecution carried the burden of proof.
Prosecution welcomes conviction
Director of Public Prosecutions Claudette Thompson welcomed the outcome, Radio Jamaica reports. She credited the prosecutors’ preparation, legal research and cooperation with investigators, while acknowledging difficulties securing witness participation.
Reading the outcome: three separate stages
JNN context: The verdict, sentence and proposed appeal answer different questions. Monday’s verdict establishes the trial outcome: a murder conviction. The January hearing is the scheduled sentencing stage. The defence’s announcement describes its intention to challenge the conviction; the reporting reviewed for this article does not establish that an appeal has already been filed or decided.
This distinction also helps place the earlier caution-statement dispute in context. That dispute was part of the evidence contested at trial. Williams’s continued criticism explains the defence’s response to losing the case; it does not itself change the jury’s verdict.
Sources and reporting note
This report draws on the following secondary court reports and post-verdict interviews. Jamaica News Now has not independently reviewed a trial transcript or an appeal filing.