Latest News
Parliament | Foreign policy

Golding Denies Being Pushed, Calls for McKenzie Apology After Parliament Clash

Mark Golding denies being pushed, backs Mikael Phillips’ apology and calls for Desmond McKenzie to apologise. Updated accounts and the Cuba debate explained.

By | Jamaica News Now | Published 4 November 2026 | Updated 5 November 2026 | House sitting: 3 November 2026

Update — 5 November 2026: Added Golding’s response from the supplied interview, Phillips’ apology and the Government’s competing account. The original report on the November 3 sitting is retained below. Corrected Phillips’ constituency to Manchester North Western.

Opposition Leader Mark Golding has denied being pushed during the confrontation involving Opposition MP Mikael Phillips and Government MP Desmond McKenzie at Gordon House, while calling on McKenzie to apologise for his role in the exchange.

In an interview recording supplied to Jamaica News Now, Golding said there had been no physical altercation. He acknowledged that someone might have bumped into him accidentally but maintained that he had not been pushed.

Golding supported Phillips’ decision to apologise to Jamaicans for using an expletive, saying the Manchester North Western MP had acted appropriately by expressing regret. He attributed the outburst to tensions surrounding the parliamentary proceedings and something subsequently said to Phillips. However, he argued that accountability needed to be balanced and that McKenzie should also apologise.

Apology and competing accounts

In a statement reported on November 4 by the Jamaica Observer, Phillips acknowledged that his response was inappropriate. He alleged that McKenzie made repeated offensive references to his deceased mother after the Speaker left the chamber. Phillips denied pushing Golding or physically touching the Government MPs who intervened.

Deputy Leader of Government Business Robert Morgan gave a different account. In the Observer’s report of his statement, Morgan said McKenzie urged Phillips to show respect to the Speaker, after which Phillips used expletives and moved aggressively towards McKenzie, requiring colleagues to restrain him.

The Gleaner reported that the governing Jamaica Labour Party disputed Phillips’ explanation and called for sanctions. Those demands do not by themselves establish that Parliament has imposed a penalty.

What the evidence does and does not establish

The distinction between a participant’s account and footage of an event matters here. The supplied clip records Golding’s explanation after the confrontation; it does not show the confrontation or independently establish the words exchanged.

Comparison of the disputed accounts
IssueAccounts and evidence limits
Was Golding pushed?Golding denies it in the supplied interview; Phillips also denies it. Morgan cited apparent physical contact in footage. Contact and a deliberate push are different claims; the interview alone cannot resolve the footage.
What prompted Phillips’ response?Phillips alleges offensive references to his late mother. Morgan describes an intervention about respect for the Speaker. The alleged remarks remain disputed.
Has a sanction been imposed?The linked reporting establishes demands for sanctions. The interview provides no formal ruling or disciplinary outcome.

Asked about the possibility of a censure motion arising from the incident, Golding said further political action would not surprise him. He accused the Government of using the confrontation to divert attention from Jamaica’s handling of the Cuba vote. That is his political assessment, not a verified finding about the Government’s intentions.

Reporting note: This update draws directly on the supplied 1 minute 51 second interview and the three linked secondary reports. Jamaica News Now has not independently reviewed the full confrontation or obtained a disciplinary ruling. No third-party video or image is reproduced.

Background: the November 3 sitting

A heated debate over Jamaica’s decision to abstain from a United Nations vote on the US embargo against Cuba ended in a stand-up protest and the adjournment of the House of Representatives on Tuesday, November 3. Tensions continued after the sitting, when two MPs became involved in a verbal confrontation.

The dispute centred on an Opposition motion seeking to censure the Government over its handling of the Cuba issue. Reports by the Jamaica Observer say the motion was brought by St Andrew Western MP Anthony Hylton and called for an apology to Parliament and a detailed account of how the abstention was authorised.

How the dispute unfolded

Speaker Juliet Holness ruled that the censure motion would be debated on Tuesday, although the Opposition had preferred that it be taken at a later sitting. Hylton argued that Parliament should have been told the Government was considering a change in Jamaica’s position before the House debated Cuba on October 27.

After Leader of Government Business Floyd Green responded, he called for the debate to end. Opposition members objected and stood in protest. The disagreement disrupted proceedings before the House was adjourned, according to the Observer’s account.

After the formal sitting, Manchester North Western MP Mikael Phillips and Government MP Desmond McKenzie became involved in a separate verbal exchange as Holness was leaving the chamber. The Observer reported that McKenzie intervened after Phillips criticised the Speaker, and that MPs including Health Minister Dr Christopher Tufton and State Minister Zavia Mayne stepped in to prevent the confrontation from becoming physical. The report described a verbal confrontation; it did not report that a physical fight occurred.

What the Opposition motion asked for

The motion sought to have Parliament censure the Government for not disclosing a proposed policy change during the October 27 debate on Cuba’s economic and humanitarian situation. It also called for the Government to apologise and explain who authorised Jamaica’s abstention, when voting instructions were sent to Jamaica’s UN representative, and whether Cuba had been consulted or amendments to the resolution proposed.

The motion followed Jamaica’s October 28 abstention from the annual UN General Assembly resolution calling for an end to the US embargo. The Observer reported that this was the first time Jamaica had not voted in favour since the resolution was introduced in 1992.

Government’s position

Foreign Affairs Minister Kamina Johnson Smith has acknowledged that the abstention marked a shift in policy. She has said Jamaica remains opposed to unilateral restrictions but believes a broader approach involving dialogue between Washington and Havana, reforms in Cuba and respect for human rights could be more constructive.

Johnson Smith has also argued that the October 27 parliamentary motion did not instruct the Government to vote for the UN resolution or bind the executive to a particular voting position. In a statement reported by The Gleaner, she said Parliament’s role in debating policy should be distinguished from the executive’s responsibility for foreign relations.

The Opposition, meanwhile, has questioned the timing and handling of the policy shift. In a report published after Jamaica abstained, The Gleaner reported that Opposition spokesperson Donna Scott-Mottley called for an explanation and questioned the apparent difference between the parliamentary debate and the UN vote.

Why the distinction matters

The parliamentary motion and the UN vote were related but separate events. The motion expressed Parliament’s position on Cuba’s economic and humanitarian situation; the Government says it did not direct Jamaica’s UN vote. The Opposition’s complaint is that the Government did not adequately disclose its intended change before that vote.

The Tuesday protest and post-sitting confrontation brought that policy dispute into public view, but they did not resolve it. The key outstanding issue is whether Parliament was given enough information to understand the Government’s position before Jamaica abstained.

Sources and reporting note

This report draws on the Jamaica Observer’s account of the House debate, its report on the exchange between Phillips and McKenzie, and The Gleaner’s report on Johnson Smith’s response and the Opposition’s concerns. The original November 4 report did not independently review a full audiovisual record of the sitting; descriptions of the exchanges are attributed to the published reports.