Two men were fatally shot by police on Old Greenvale Road in Mandeville, Manchester, on Monday, October 19. Police describe an armed confrontation; relatives of one of the deceased dispute his involvement in wrongdoing.
This report brings together the police account and the family’s response, as reported separately by the Jamaica Observer, and explains the limits of the aftermath footage supplied to Jamaica News Now. Neither account has been independently established by this newsroom.
What police say happened
In the Observer’s initial report, Manchester divisional head Deputy Superintendent Odean Dennis said officers received information about people in a silver Toyota Axio allegedly threatening someone with a firearm. He said a team located a matching car around 6:40 a.m., signalled it to stop and came under fire.
According to Dennis’s account, officers fired back and two wounded men were found in the car. He also reported the recovery of a Smith & Wesson M&P rifle and ammunition. These details are attributed to the police; the reported recovery does not by itself establish each occupant’s actions.
The family’s account
In a separate Observer report, relatives identified one of the deceased as Roshane Gayle, 34, a construction worker from the Southfield area of St Elizabeth. They gathered outside Mandeville police station to protest his death.
His relatives said he had obtained a lift in the car and denied that he was a criminal. His mother said he had been visiting his girlfriend in Mandeville and intended to return to St Elizabeth that Monday. Those statements remain the family’s account, rather than independently verified findings.
What the footage establishes — and what it cannot
The supplied recording shows police vehicles and yellow tape across a roadway. A silver-coloured car is visible beyond the cordon with its boot and at least one door open. These observations concern the scene after the event.
The recording does not show the shooting. It cannot establish who fired first, which person possessed a weapon, or what either man was doing immediately before shots were fired. The vehicle’s appearance is not proof of the occupants’ conduct. Audio has not been transcribed for this review.
How to read the competing accounts
The key distinction is between an allegation about an encounter and evidence about an individual. Police reporting a weapon in a vehicle and relatives describing a passenger’s reason for travelling are different claims. One does not automatically resolve the other.
A useful next update would distinguish each man’s alleged actions, explain the evidence supporting that account and identify which details have been independently examined. A full reconstruction would need evidence from before and during the encounter, beyond images of the cordoned-off scene.
Readers should therefore avoid treating the initial label “gunmen” as an established finding about both men. Equally, a relative’s denial is not a completed investigation. This page records the disagreement without deciding it.
Sources and publication note
Published October 20, 2026, about the October 19 incident. This website version adds the subsequently available police details and family response to the earlier short draft. It relies on secondary reporting and visual review of a supplied recording, not an on-scene interview or an independent reconstruction. No finding about lawfulness or individual responsibility is made.
