Latest News
Justice

15-Month Transcript Delay Derails Crown’s Appeal in Missionaries’ Murder Case

Reporting on October 10 detailed how a missed statutory deadline prevented review of Andre Thomas’s minimum term before parole.

By | Jamaica News Now | Published 11 October 2026 | Saturday’s news cycle
Illustrative title card: 15-Month Transcript Delay Derails Crown’s Appeal in Missionaries’ Murder Case
Jamaica News Now title card. AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.

News brief · This is a short, dated summary. Consult its linked sources and the news archive for context and follow-up reporting.

A delay in obtaining a trial transcript prevented prosecutors from pursuing a sentence appeal in the case against Andre Thomas, convicted of killing two American missionaries in St Mary, The Gleaner reported on October 10.

The newspaper said the transcript took 15 months to arrive, leaving the Crown unable to have its appeal heard within the statutory 12-month period. The report concerns an earlier court decision, rather than a ruling delivered on Saturday.

Sentence remains in force

Thomas received concurrent life sentences in November 2023, with a minimum of 26 years before parole eligibility. The prosecution sought to challenge that punishment as too lenient, but the Court of Appeal struck out its appeal and refused a renewed application.

According to the published account, the court concluded that a new application could not restart the statutory deadline. The Crown had filed its original application on time.

Separate appeal still pending

Thomas’s own challenge to his conviction and sentence remained awaiting a hearing, the report said. The failed Crown appeal does not overturn his convictions or mean he has been released.

The case illustrates how delays in producing records can prevent an appeal from reaching consideration of the sentence itself.

Sources

Coverage of the 10 October 2026 news cycle. Sources checked on 11 October 2026; event dates are stated in the report.