Latest News
Politics · Parliament

Crown Lands Bill Dispute Sparks Tense Exchanges in Parliament

The September 29 sitting saw the Crown Lands Reform Bill referred to the Attorney General amid tense exchanges over parliamentary procedure.

By | Jamaica News Now · Published 30 September 2026 · Sitting: 29 September 2026

The dispute over Opposition Leader Mark Golding’s proposed Crown Lands Reform Bill returned to Parliament on Tuesday, September 29, prompting tense exchanges over the Speaker’s authority and the Opposition’s opportunity to respond. The legislation was not tabled, with Speaker Juliet Holness announcing that she had referred it to the Attorney General for advice.

The proposal seeks to help Jamaicans who have occupied government-owned land for extended periods obtain legal ownership. However, its introduction remains caught in a disagreement over constitutional requirements and parliamentary procedure.

Further legal advice sought

Holness told the House that Parliament had received a further revised version on Saturday. Both the original and latest drafts had been sent to the Attorney General, following questions about the legal advice previously provided to Parliament.

The Speaker maintained that her responsibility was to determine whether the House could lawfully proceed. She cited Standing Order 40A(3), saying it prevents the House from proceeding with a Bill where the presiding member considers that doing so would contravene Section 55 of the Constitution.

Golding has disputed her handling of the proposal, maintaining that he was prevented from introducing it and arguing that constitutional concerns could be addressed during the legislative process. The disagreement concerns both the reforms and the stage at which legal objections should be resolved.

Opposition attempts to respond

When Golding rose to respond to the Speaker’s opening statement, he was reminded of the Standing Orders. Leader of Government Business Floyd Green said a response was not permitted at that point in proceedings.

According to IRIE FM’s account, Opposition members rose from their seats before sitting again after Green outlined the procedural rules. Golding subsequently raised a point of order concerning the House’s agenda, while Holness reiterated her power to regulate proceedings. Leader of Opposition Business Phillip Paulwell also attempted to intervene, but the Speaker maintained her position.

No decision on the proposed reforms

The exchanges left the central issue unresolved. Holness said she would consider the Attorney General’s advice before deciding the next step. Tuesday’s sitting produced a referral for further legal consideration, rather than the tabling or passage of the proposal.

Separate concerns over Parliament’s administration

Separately, Parliament faced scrutiny following Deputy Clerk Christopher Cowan’s resignation. The Gleaner reported that Cowan alleged retaliatory treatment and interference with his office. Paulwell expressed concern about instability and senior staff turnover. These remain Cowan’s allegations; the newspaper reported that Clerk Colleen Lowe had not responded by its publication deadline. This development formed part of the wider parliamentary backdrop, rather than a confirmed decision taken during Tuesday’s sitting.

For people hoping the proposed Crown Lands reforms will provide a route to ownership, the next development to watch is the Attorney General’s advice and the Speaker’s subsequent ruling.