Latest News
Editorial · Recovery and resilience

Parottee Must Have a Real Choice on Relocation

Jamaica’s plan for 100 homes in Luana must protect residents’ safety, livelihoods and right to make an informed choice about Parottee’s future.

By | Published 30 October 2026

The future of Parottee should be decided with its residents, not for them. After Hurricane Melissa devastated the coastal community, families are being asked to weigh a difficult choice: remain close to home, family and work, or move inland to reduce exposure to future storms.

The Government says it will advance 100 prefabricated homes at Luana Phase 3 for eligible Parottee residents who are living in unsafe conditions and are willing to relocate. Prime Minister Andrew Holness has described the move as voluntary and said the homes must have prepared sites, utilities and community infrastructure before families occupy them. That commitment is a necessary starting point. It is not yet a complete recovery plan.

Recent reporting from Parottee describes residents rebuilding homes and businesses, fishing and operating boat tours, while some say their family graves and deep community ties are among the reasons they do not want to leave. Those attachments should not be dismissed as resistance to progress. They are part of what relocation would mean in practice.

A choice must be informed

Residents need clear, written answers before they can make a meaningful decision. The Government should publish the risk assessments behind its advice, explain which parts of Parottee are considered unsafe and why, and set out what protections or building standards may be possible for people who remain. The evidence should be understandable and open to questions from residents.

Families considering Luana also need to know when homes and services will be ready, how eligibility will be decided, what support is available for moving, and what happens to land and property in Parottee. These details should be shared directly with residents, with time to review them and a clear way to correct errors or appeal decisions. An offer is not a genuine option if families must accept it before they understand its terms.

Homes alone will not replace livelihoods

For fishers and boat-tour operators, moving inland may affect access to the sea, customers, equipment and income. A new house can provide shelter, but it cannot by itself restore a livelihood. Any relocation package should be developed with the people affected and include practical measures to help workers continue earning, such as access to work sites, transport, secure equipment storage and support for small businesses.

Residents who decide to stay also need timely recovery assistance and plain guidance about safer rebuilding. That does not mean the state should ignore a serious risk or promise that any location can be made safe. It means advice must be paired with support, and the limits of that support must be explained honestly.

Respect must be matched by delivery

The Government has said it will not force residents to move. That assurance should be reflected in every part of the process: fair eligibility rules, transparent assessments, meaningful consultation and no loss of dignity for people who make different choices. Authorities should publish a timetable, identify the agencies responsible and report progress on homes, infrastructure and livelihood support.

Parottee’s residents should not have to choose between safety and belonging, or between a secure home and the ability to earn a living. Some may decide that relocation is right for them; others may remain. Government has a duty to make the risks clear and to ensure that either decision is made with full information and practical support.

The measure of this recovery will be more than the number of houses announced. It will be whether people have a real choice, whether the promised homes are ready with essential services, and whether residents can rebuild a dignified life wherever they decide to live.

Sources and further reading