Latest News
Latest development, 10 November 2026: Ruddock convicted; defence plans appeal.
Court report

Pathways Trial: JP Defends Ruddock’s Caution Statement as Recording Dispute Continues

A justice of the peace says Andre Ruddock was advised of his rights, while defence lawyers question whether the private consultation was recorded and how advice about questioning was given.

By | Jamaica News Now | Published 23 October 2026

News report · Information checked for 23 October 2026. Follow the linked sources for later updates.

A justice of the peace testified in the Home Circuit Court that murder accused Andre Ruddock was advised of his right to remain silent and was offered a private discussion before giving a caution statement in the Pathways International trial. The defence has challenged whether that consultation was genuinely private and whether the advice about a later question-and-answer session was clear, according to The Gleaner’s October 23 court report.

What the JP told the court

The witness said Ruddock could speak with the JPs privately and was advised about legal representation and the option not to speak. The JP also testified that he did not know recording equipment had remained on during the preliminary discussion. Police witnesses had earlier testified that video recording continued while they left the room.

Why the recording issue matters

The testimony puts two questions before the court: what Ruddock was told about his rights, and whether the circumstances allowed him to speak privately with the JPs. The defence questioned the recording, the JP’s understanding of privacy and advice that appeared to connect giving a caution statement with taking part in a question-and-answer session. The JP rejected the suggestion that his advice was misleading, while acknowledging he did not know the discussion was being recorded.

A contested account, not a ruling

The JP’s evidence is testimony, not a judicial finding that the statement is admissible or that Ruddock is guilty. The prosecution must establish its case and the defence may challenge the evidence. The court will determine how to treat the statement under the applicable law after considering the record and arguments.

Background to the case

Ruddock is on trial for the October 2021 killing of Taneka Gardner at the Pathways International Kingdom Restoration Ministries compound in St James. Prosecutors allege Gardner was killed during an event at the church and that Ruddock acted on instructions from the now-deceased church leader Kevin Smith. These remain allegations to be decided by the court.

What to watch next

The trial continued on Friday, October 23, according to the report. The next useful developments are any further testimony about the recording and consultation, the court’s treatment of the caution statement, and the judge’s directions to the jury. The earlier testimony about the statement and the separate police-sergeant account are linked below for context.

Sources and further reading

This report summarises the linked reporting and official material. Jamaica News Now did not conduct original interviews for this article.