Jamaican-born televangelist Paul Lewis has been sentenced to 14 years in prison in New York after a jury convicted him of repeatedly sexually abusing an 11-year-old girl who belonged to his Brooklyn church congregation.
Lewis, 63, was sentenced on Monday, October 26, by Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Naiburg. He must also serve 10 years of post-release supervision after completing his prison term, the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office said.
The conviction marks a sharp reversal from Lewis’s earlier legal history in Jamaica. He was acquitted in 2011 of charges arising from allegations involving two teenage girls in Westmoreland. The Jamaican case was separate from the New York prosecution, which concerned a different complainant and events in Brooklyn in 2014.
The Brooklyn case
Prosecutors said Lewis was pastor of Messengers for Christ World Healing Center in Brooklyn, a church with branches in Jamaica, Trinidad and Germany. The girl’s family were members of his congregation.
According to the evidence presented at trial, Lewis picked up the child from her home on multiple occasions between September 3 and December 23, 2014, saying he was taking her to get food. Prosecutors said he sexually assaulted her in his vehicle near a McDonald’s in Bedford-Stuyvesant. On another occasion, he took her to a Brooklyn brownstone, where he sexually assaulted her.
The girl reported the abuse to police on February 26, 2024, when she went to the 81st Precinct stationhouse. Lewis was arrested following an investigation. A jury found him guilty on September 24, 2026, of first-degree course of sexual conduct against a child.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said the sentence held Lewis accountable and could provide the victim with a measure of closure. The District Attorney’s announcement did not identify the victim, in keeping with the protections generally afforded to children in sexual-abuse cases.
Earlier case in Jamaica
Lewis’s Jamaican case began in 2009, when he was charged with one count of carnal abuse and two counts of indecent assault involving two girls, then aged 15 and 14. The allegations related to an encounter in Negril after Lewis, who was visiting Westmoreland as a guest preacher, met one of the girls at a church gathering in Little London.
Those allegations were tried in the Westmoreland Circuit Court. In June 2011, a seven-member jury found Lewis not guilty. The trial was held in camera, and Lewis denied the allegations. The verdict meant he was acquitted of the charges; it was not a conviction or a finding of guilt.
The Jamaican proceedings also produced a separate case concerning an alleged attempt to pervert the course of justice. That matter arose after Lewis was accused of trying to influence a witness in the sexual-offence case. It was a distinct charge from the allegations for which he was acquitted.
From Jamaican-born preacher to Brooklyn pastor
Lewis was born in Jamaica and later became a prominent US-based preacher. He founded and led Messengers for Christ Ministries World Healing Center, and contemporary Jamaican coverage described him as a charismatic evangelist with a large following at home and overseas. His ministry also held services and crusades in Jamaica.
The New York case concerns conduct prosecutors said occurred while Lewis was serving as a pastor in Brooklyn. His conviction and sentence do not change the outcome of the earlier Jamaican trial, but they place his name before the courts again in a separate case involving the sexual abuse of a child.
The sentence handed down in Brooklyn on October 26 includes 14 years’ imprisonment followed by 10 years of post-release supervision.
Reading the two cases together
The dates matter: 2009 was the year of the Jamaican charges; the acquittal came in June 2011. The Brooklyn prosecution concerned conduct in 2014, a police report in 2024 and a conviction in September 2026. These are separate proceedings, so the New York verdict should not be described as a reversal or reopening of the Jamaican acquittal. The historical witness-influence allegation is also not evidence of a conviction in that separate matter; this report does not establish its final outcome.