As reported 27 September 2026. The proposed lawyers’ withdrawal is scheduled to begin Monday, September 28; this report does not confirm that it has started.
Jamaica’s criminal courts could face disruption from Monday. Defence lawyers say they still intend to withdraw their services for a week unless their concerns about mandatory sentences under the 2022 Firearms Act are addressed. Justice Minister Delroy Chuck is defending the law while acknowledging that some provisions are being examined.
The dispute centres on a question with serious consequences: how much freedom should a judge have when sentencing someone convicted of a firearm offence?
Read the September 23 protest report
The lawyers’ concerns
Lawyers object to mandatory minimum sentences under the Firearms (Prohibition, Restriction and Regulation) Act, 2022. They argue that the rules can prevent judges from giving enough weight to the facts of an individual case. Among the examples they have raised are cases involving imitation firearms and circumstances they say should be treated as exceptional. They have also warned that the sentencing rules may discourage early guilty pleas and add pressure to an already busy court system. Those are the lawyers’ arguments; the effects they describe have not been established simply by the fact of the protest.
A planned withdrawal
Members of the legal profession held a silent protest outside the Supreme Court on Wednesday. Representatives then met Minister Chuck on Thursday. According to reporting on the meeting, the lawyers said they were disappointed that no timetable for legislative changes was provided. They have maintained their plan to withdraw criminal court services from Monday, September 28, through Friday, October 2. At this point, that is a planned withdrawal, not one that has begun.
The minister’s response
Chuck’s response is that the law must account for victims of gun crime as well as the rights of accused people. He has said the Government will look at exceptional cases, including some involving imitation firearms, while resisting changes that he believes would weaken the response to serious gun offending. He has also argued that the Act is helping to reduce murders and shootings.
For now, neither side has announced a resolution. If the withdrawal proceeds, its immediate effect will be felt by people with cases before the criminal courts—including accused persons, victims and witnesses waiting for proceedings to move forward. The key development to watch is whether further talks produce a specific proposal or timetable before Monday.
Background reporting: Jamaica Gleaner. Figures and testimony are attributed in the report.
