
Kingston Western Member of Parliament Desmond McKenzie has rejected calls to apologise for his involvement in Tuesday’s confrontation at Gordon House, maintaining that he did nothing wrong and did not breach Parliament’s Standing Orders.
Speaking at a Jamaica Labour Party media briefing on Friday, November 6, McKenzie disputed Opposition MP Mikael Phillips’ account of the exchange and defended his intervention as a response to the treatment of House Speaker Juliet Holness.
A reporter asks McKenzie about Phillips’ allegation that he made an offensive reference to the Manchester North Western MP’s deceased mother.
McKenzie responds that he had already publicly explained his remarks. According to his account, he asked Phillips whether he would want anyone to treat his mother in the manner in which the Speaker was being treated. He challenges Phillips to specify precisely what he alleges was said.
Asked directly whether he owed Jamaicans an apology, McKenzie maintains that he remained standing at his seat while the Speaker was leaving the chamber and had not violated parliamentary rules.
His explanation remains disputed. Phillips said in a statement on Wednesday that McKenzie repeatedly made an offensive reference to his late mother, prompting an angry response. Phillips acknowledged using an expletive, described his reaction as inappropriate and apologised to the Jamaican people.
JLP challenges criticism of parliamentary conduct
The questioning then turns to the wider impact of parliamentary behaviour, including the example elected representatives set for children.
Responding, Senator Abka Fitz-Henley, chairman of the JLP’s Communications Task Force, acknowledges that parliamentarians must consider how their conduct affects people watching proceedings. However, he rejects the suggestion that responsibility for Tuesday’s confrontation should be shared equally between Government and Opposition members.
Fitz-Henley accuses Opposition members of aggressive and inappropriate behaviour. He also criticises sections of civil society and the media, arguing that misconduct by PNP representatives should receive the same scrutiny applied to Government members.
His comments include an allegation of physical contact with the Speaker. That issue is contested: Holness has accused St Andrew South Western MP Dr Angela Brown Burke of shoving her as she left the chamber. Brown Burke denies shoving the Speaker, while acknowledging that she called her a coward.
Tuesday’s confrontation followed a contentious sitting over an Opposition censure motion concerning Jamaica’s abstention on a United Nations resolution calling for an end to the United States embargo against Cuba. Opposition members protested the move to close the debate before the sitting was adjourned.
The dispute has since prompted an effort to bring parliamentary leaders together.
Speaker seeks meeting with parliamentary leaders
According to Nationwide News, Holness wrote on November 5 to Leader of Government Business Floyd Green and Leader of Opposition Business Phillip Paulwell, requesting an urgent meeting to review the breakdown of order and agree on measures to prevent a recurrence.
She proposed November 9 at 10 a.m., with November 10 at the same time as an alternative. Those were proposed meeting dates, rather than a confirmed arrangement in the report.
The competing accounts leave unresolved what precisely triggered the confrontation. McKenzie’s assertion that he complied with the Standing Orders is his defence; it does not, by itself, amount to a parliamentary ruling on the incident.
Reporting note and related coverage
This report draws on a supplied recording of the November 6 media briefing and the linked secondary reporting below. The recording documents the briefing responses; it does not establish the exact words exchanged on November 3. The distinction between a participant’s defence and a parliamentary finding remains important when assessing these accounts.
- Amber News: November 6 JLP briefing
- The Gleaner: Phillips’ statement
- Nationwide News: Speaker requests meeting
Read our original report on the Cuba motion and Parliament confrontation.